Bagels
Half Dozen Bagels
$9.00
6 bagels of your choice.
Dozen Bagels
$18.00
Bagels by the dozen. Don't forget to click 3 bagels at the end you get 14 in our Dozen :)
Plain Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Onion Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Salt Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Cinnamon Sugar Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Poppy Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Sesame Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Plain French Toast Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Egg French Toast Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Cinnamon Raisin French Toast Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Egg Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Egg Everything Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Asiago Everything
$2.00
Asiago
$2.00
Blueberry Crunch Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Blueberry Bagel
$1.75
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Swiss Cheese Bagel - Swiss
$2.00
Swiss Cheese Bagel - Swiss Onion
$2.00
Gluten Free Bagel
$2.00
Just loose bagel can not add cream cheese or butter.
Mini Bagels
Dozen Mini Bagels
$14.50
Sesame Mini Bagels - Regular
$1.50
Sesame Mini Bagels - Dozen
$14.50
Plain Mini Bagels - Regular
$1.50
Plain Mini Bagels - Dozen
$14.50
Poppy Mini Bagels - Regular
$1.50
Poppy Mini Bagels - Dozen
$14.50
Mini Bagel with TOPPING - Plain Cream Cheese
$3.25
In notes write what kind if mini ( Plain, Ev, Poppy, Ses) and if you pick Specialty Cream cheese what kind!
Mini Bagel with TOPPING - Specialty
$3.50
In notes write what kind if mini ( Plain, Ev, Poppy, Ses) and if you pick Specialty Cream cheese what kind!
Mini Bagel with TOPPING - Butter
$2.25
In notes write what kind if mini ( Plain, Ev, Poppy, Ses) and if you pick Specialty Cream cheese what kind!
Mini Bagel with TOPPING - Straw Jelly
$2.50
In notes write what kind if mini ( Plain, Ev, Poppy, Ses) and if you pick Specialty Cream cheese what kind!
Mini Bagel with TOPPING - Grape Jelly
$2.50
In notes write what kind if mini ( Plain, Ev, Poppy, Ses) and if you pick Specialty Cream cheese what kind!
Mini Bagel with TOPPING - PB J
$3.50
In notes write what kind if mini ( Plain, Ev, Poppy, Ses) and if you pick Specialty Cream cheese what kind!
Mini Bagel with TOPPING - Peanut Butter
$2.50
In notes write what kind if mini ( Plain, Ev, Poppy, Ses) and if you pick Specialty Cream cheese what kind!
Everything Mini Bagels - Regular
$1.50
Everything Mini Bagels - Dozen
$14.50
Spreads
Cream Cheese Spread
$4.50
Choose between regular cream cheese and low fat cream cheese.
Buttered Bagel
$4.00
Cinnamon-Sugar Butter Spread
$4.25
Jelly Spread
$4.00
Veggie Specialty Spread
$5.25
Scallion Specialty Spread
$5.25
Lox Spread
$6.75
Peanut Butter
$5.00
On your choice of a Bagel
PB & Jelly Spread
$5.50
Choice of strawberry or grape spread.
Strawberry Specialty Spread
$5.25
Cinnamon-Raisin Walnut Specialty Spread
$5.25
Olive Specialty Spread
$5.25
8oz Spreads
8oz Spreads
$0.00
Smoked Fish on a Bagel
Whitefish Bagel
$11.50
Nova Bagel
$13.00
Nova & Cream Cheese Bagel
$14.00
Breakfast Sandwiches
Egg Breakfast Sandwich
$6.75
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.
Egg & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
$7.75
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, twist or bread.
Meat Breakfast Sandwich
$7.75
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.
Meat & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
$8.25
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.
Meat & Egg Breakfast Sandwich
$8.25
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.
Meat, Egg & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
$8.75
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread.
Soups
Soup - Small
$5.75
Call for the flavors at 609-737-8990 Small 12oz Large 16oz
Soup - Large
$6.75
Call for the flavors at 609-737-8990 Small 12oz Large 16oz
Soup - Small (Chili)
$6.75
Call for the flavors at 609-737-8990 Small 12oz Large 16oz
Soup - Large (Chili)
$7.75
Call for the flavors at 609-737-8990 Small 12oz Large 16oz
Create Your Own Sandwich
Turkey Sandwich
$10.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Ham Sandwich
$10.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Chicken Sandwich
$10.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Pastrami Sandwich
$11.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Corned Beef Sandwich
$11.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Salami Sandwich
$9.00
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Cappicola Sandwich
$10.00
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Cheese Sandwich
$8.00
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Homemade Chicken Salad Sandwich
$11.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Homemade Tuna Salad Sandwich
$11.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Homemade Egg Salad Sandwich
$11.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
BLT Sandwich
$10.50
Bacon, lettuce & tomato. Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Roast Beef Sandwich
$11.50
Served on your choice of bagel, wrap, or bread. Served with a pickle.
Hoagies
Italian Hoagie
$10.50
Ham, salami, cappicola, and Provolone cheese served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Turkey & Cheese Hoagie
$11.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Chicken Breast & Cheese Hoagie
$11.00
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Pastrami Hoagie
$12.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Corned Beef & Cheese Hoagie
$11.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Homemade Tuna Hoagie
$12.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Chicken Salad Hoagie
$12.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Egg Salad Hoagie
$12.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Roast Beef Hoagie
$12.50
Served on a base of your choice with a pickle.
Vegetarian Combos
15 Vegetarian Combo
$12.00
Fresh Mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato & roasted red peppers with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
16 Vegetarian Combo
$12.00
Roasted red pepper hummus, sprouts, carrots, cucumber & tomato.
17 Vegetarian Combo
$12.00
Your choice of low fat veggie cream cheese, low fat scallion cream cheese, or melted Colby Jack cheese with lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrots & honey mustard.
18 Vegetarian Combo
$12.00
Sprouts, lettuce, tomato, carrots, cucumber, & onions with Lite Ranch dressing.
Sandwich Combos
1 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Maple honey ham with scallion cream cheese, cucumbers, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
2 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Hot pastrami with melted Swiss cheese, homemade coleslaw and cajun mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
4 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Salsalito turkey breast, melted Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
5 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Ham and turkey, Monterey Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard and mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
6 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Chicken breast, melted Muenster cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
7 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Cracked Peppermill turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and Russian dressing. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
8 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Homemade famous chicken salad, Provolone cheese, bacon and honey mustard. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
11 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Hot corned beef with sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese, and Russian Dressing. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
12 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Buffalo chicken breast, Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo or Blue cheese dressing. Can be served hot or cold. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
13 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Chicken breast, roasted red peppers, melted Provolone cheese and mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
14 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Maple honey turkey breast, melted Monterey Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
19 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
One of our most popular sandwiches! BBQ chicken breast, melted Colby Jack cheese, minced onions, BBQ sauce, bacon and mayo. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Olympic Sandwich
$13.50
Chicken breast, melted Gouda cheese, avocado, cranberries, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Apple/Brie & Chicken Sandwich
$13.25
Chicken breast, melted Brie cheese, spinach and pesto. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Spicy Hot Sandwich
$13.50
Buffalo chicken breast, melted Colby Jack cheese, cream cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes, and Tostitos. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Blazing Chicken Sandwich
$13.50
Buffalo chicken breast, Blue cheese, melted Cheddar cheese, shredded lettuce, avocado, bacon and hot sauce. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
3 Sandwich Combo
$13.25
Roast beef, melted Cheddar cheese, minced onions and horseradish sauce. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Stoked Combo
$13.50
Chicken breast with melted cheddar, spinach, bacon , avocado and topped with ranch
WeMakeWich
$13.50
Bacon, melted Pepper jack Cheese, Red Onion, Avocado and Cajun Mayo
Low Fat Sandwich Combos
9 Low Fat Sandwich Combo
$12.00
Maple honey ham, Lite scallion cream cheese, cucumbers and tomato. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
10 Low Fat Sandwich Combo
$12.00
Cracked Pepper Mill Turkey, tomato, onions and spicy mustard. Your choice of coleslaw, potato salad, macaroni salad, or small bag of chips and a pickle or upgrade to Deep River chips.
Tossed Salad Combos
Chef's Salad
$13.50
Boar's Head turkey, ham, and roast beef with cheese and half boiled egg. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Chicken B.L.T. Salad
$13.50
Oven roasted chicken breast with Muenster cheese and bacon. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Just Veggies & Cheese Salad
$13.50
Choose two cheeses with roasted red peppers and hard boiled egg. Option to add hot peppers. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Roasted Red Pepper & Chicken Breast Salad
$13.50
Chicken breast with roasted red peppers and Provolone cheese. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Three Scoop Sampler Salad
$13.50
Choose three scoops of our homemade chicken, tuna, or egg salad. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Single Scoop Salad
$12.50
Choose one scoop of homemade chicken, tuna, or egg salad. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Cobb Salad
$13.50
Chicken breast, bacon, crumbled Blue cheese and hard boiled egg. Served on a bed of mixed greens with carrots, cucumbers, tomato, with your choice of dressing and a mini bagel.
Chicken Caesar Salad
$13.50
Mixed greens, chicken breast and Asiago cheese with bagel croutons and Caesar dressing. Served with your choice of mini bagel.
Create Your Own Salad
$13.50
Choose from any one meat, one cheese, and any of our salad toppings. Served with your choice of mini bagel.
By the Pound or Half Pound
Fresh Sliced Nova - Half Pound
$17.25
Fresh Sliced Nova - 1 Pound
$34.50
Chicken Salad - Half Pound
$7.00
Chicken Salad - 1 Pound
$14.00
Tuna Salad - Half Pound
$7.00
Tuna Salad - 1 Pound
$14.00
Egg Salad - Half Pound
$7.00
Egg Salad - 1 Pound
$14.00
Potato Salad - Half Pound
$5.00
Potato Salad - 1 Pound
$10.00
Coleslaw - Half Pound
$5.00
Coleslaw - 1 Pound
$10.00
Macaroni Salad - Half Pound
$5.00
Macaroni Salad - 1 Pound
$10.00
Extra Sides
Side Potato Salad
$2.50
Side Macaroni Salad
$2.50
Deep River Chips
$3.00
Choose between plain, BBQ, salt & vinegar, sour cream & onion, and jalapeno.
Side Coleslaw
$2.50
Bag of Chips
$2.50
Choose between regular or sour cream.
Drinks
Pepsi
$3.75
Coke
$3.75
Diet Pepsi
$3.75
Diet Coke
$3.75
Diet Lemon Snapple
$3.50
Snapple Lemon
$3.50
Diet Peach Snapple
$3.50
Snapple Peach
$3.50
Orange Juice
$3.75
Chocolate Milk
$3.75
Poland Spring Water
$2.50
Prime
$4.50
Coffee
Hot Regular Coffee - Small
$2.75
Hot Regular Coffee - Medium
$3.00
Hot Regular Coffee - Large
$3.25
Hot Regular Coffee - Box
$20.50
Decaf Hot Coffee - Small
$2.50
Decaf Hot Coffee - Medium
$2.75
Decaf Hot Coffee - Large
$3.00
Decaf Hot Coffee - Box
$20.50
Dark Roast Hot Coffee - Small
$3.00
Dark Roast Hot Coffee - Medium
$3.25
Dark Roast Hot Coffee - Large
$3.75
Dark Roast Hot Coffee - Box
$23.50
Flavor of the Day Hot Coffee - Small
$2.50
Flavor of the Day Hot Coffee - Medium
$2.75
Flavor of the Day Hot Coffee - Large
$3.00
Flavor of the Day Hot Coffee - Box
$20.50
Iced Coffee - Small
$3.50
Iced Coffee - Large
$4.25
Bagel Twists
Everything Bagel Twist
$5.00
Plain Bagel Twist
$5.00
Sesame Bagel Twist
$5.00
Pennington Bagel Experience offers a delightful array of bagels, sandwiches, spreads, and more, making it a go-to spot for both bagel lovers and sandwich enthusiasts. If you're in the mood for a classic, the plain, onion, or salt bagels are the perfect starting point. For something smaller, their mini bagels—available in both plain and sesame—offer a delicious bite-sized treat. Whether you’re grabbing a half dozen or a full dozen, you can be sure that each bagel is freshly baked to perfection.
When it comes to spreads, the options are indulgent and satisfying. From the rich and creamy cream cheese spread to the sweet cinnamon-sugar butter spread, there’s a flavor to complement every bagel. For those seeking something more savory, the veggie specialty spread adds a unique touch, while buttered bagels make for a simple, yet tasty snack.
If you're looking for a hearty breakfast, Pennington has you covered with a variety of breakfast sandwiches. The egg breakfast sandwich is a comforting classic, while the meat & cheese combo adds a savory punch. And for those craving a bagel with a twist, try the smoked fish options like the Nova Bagel or the Whitefish Bagel, each piled high with delicious toppings.
The sandwich selection offers something for everyone, whether you prefer a traditional deli sandwich like the pastrami or corned beef, or want to build your own creation with turkey, ham, or chicken. Vegetarians can also enjoy a range of options like the roasted red pepper & chicken breast salad or the chef’s salad.
For sides, Pennington has a variety of options, from potato salad to macaroni salad and crispy chips. Pair your meal with a refreshing soda, iced tea, or a hot coffee to round off your experience. Whether you're stopping by for a quick breakfast or enjoying a leisurely lunch, Pennington Bagel Experience delivers on flavor and freshness in every bite.